Book Reviews

Book Review: The Ninth Rain by Jen Williams


In The Ninth Rain, first in The Winnowing Flame Trilogy, Jen Williams brings a fresh and unique story to the fantasy genre; a book that strides across epic fantasy and probes the boundaries into sci-fi.

The Eboran Empire was Sarn’s first line of defense against their ancient foe, the Jure’lia. Over centuries, they would send defeating waves of attacks, only to be repelled by the Eboran warriors and their war beasts. 

They finally brought peace to Sarn, but at a dreadful cost; the annihilation of the Ju’relia meant the death of their god. Without the sustenance from their god, Ebora is collapsing in upon itself. 

This is the world we are thrust into, as alongside Tormalin, Vintage and Noon we discover the enemy may have left some surprises behind.

I came into The Ninth Rain straight off the back of The Copper Cat trilogy; my expectations were high, and I was not disappointed. It’s a beautiful progression of Jen Williams’ writing. Whereas we’re used to plenty of action and a hearty pace, here Williams presents us with something altogether more multilayered and polished. Don’t be fooled, we’re not missing any of that action or pace; but in The Ninth Rain Williams has honed her writing craft. The prose is beautiful, with care taken over wonderfully descriptive language and nuances of emotion; it is clear that time has been taken over the planning of this story and this novel does an effective job of introducing us to Williams’ new world and setting us up for the trilogy, whilst at the same time carrying an exciting plot that doesn’t drown us in exposition.

There was so much about this book that surprised me and challenged my perceptions of genre; I find myself so quick to label books and sort them into specific pigeon holes, and before I had even started I presumed The Ninth Rain was a straight-forward fantasy. There’s a griffin on the cover. The blurb promises monsters, abominations, collapsing empires, conspiracies, magic, war. There’s even a hint of pyromania. But this book refuses to be contained. There are whiffs of a dystopian society; a post-apocalyptic empire, a tyrannical dictatorship using religious fervour as a basis for institutionalised abuse. There is an exciting sci-fi element that takes you unawares, and it even flirts tentatively on the side with steam-punk.

What truly sets Williams’ writing apart, for me, is her characters. I love their depth, their complications, their moral ambiguity. You can’t always trust in the ideal that a hero will have heroic motivations; Williams’ characters are more human, we explore their weaknesses, their guilt, their realisation that there is a correct course of action but their selfish motivations are taking them down an entirely different path. This “antihero” archetype isn’t new, it’s quite popular amongst “grimdark” fantasy; the “tortured soul”. But what is different in the characters of The Ninth Rain is that they’re still ultimately lovable; you fall for them, you understand their motivations and forgive them, you hope they will learn and grow. You hope, but you’re not entirely sure, they’ll do whats right in the end.

In short, this is yet another display of Jen Williams’ apparently inexhaustible imagination. It is a world utterly different from her previous work. She carries forth her strengths (strong and diverse characters, intricate world building, original humour) and immerses you in a whole new mythology.

In the words of Dan Sutcliffe, “More please.”



P.S Thought you couldn’t beat “follow that centipede”? 


The Ninth Rain is available at The Book Depository
Purchasing books using the above link supports this blog.

8 thoughts on “Book Review: The Ninth Rain by Jen Williams

  1. Loved this review! This is on my TBR and I know the sequel is coming soon, but would you recommend reading her other series first then progressing to this? Wondering based on your comments about noting how she evolved as a writer.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. That’s a really good question… The Copper Cat trilogy felt more fun and relaxed, I may be wrong but looking back on them I get the impression that The Copper Promise was written first and then extended into a trilogy. It could have easily stood on its own, but the other continue on from it beautifully.
      The Ninth Rain, however, is clearly just the first installment in an overarching story and as such it’s somewhat slower paced and meatier…
      I’m not sure which I’d recommend first? Possibly the copper cat as all three of those are already available? I’m going to be at such a loss come the the end of the bitter twins, but of course it does mean a big reread when book three (the poison song? Am I making that up?) comes out

      Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you Anne!
      Started writing a review/discussion of A Fault With Our Stars (tried and failed to write a non spoiler review lol)
      Currently reading the sequel to The Ninth Rain, called The Bitter Twins….
      Ever busy! How about you?


    1. Thank you lovely! Obviously I’d recommend it, I’ve fallen pretty hard for Jen williams’ characters, and her writing style is so easy to read 😍 she features your typical fantasy elements but they don’t feel tired or over done as there are plenty of other things keeping it fresh


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s